Gilad Shalit’s Plight, And Israel’s Dilemma–The Forward

Haim Watzman

There are many beautiful theories about how to bring Gilad Shalit home, but it’s an ugly fact that he now has been a captive for three years. And it’s an ugly fact that a series of Israeli governments have been unable to free him. Both diplomatic and military means have failed so far. Shalit’s family and friends blame the government for not doing enough, as do many Israelis. Others, including army officers, diplomats and the families of terror victims, argue that not every price is worth paying. Gilad, they say, does not stand alone; his life is not worth more than the lives of others.

If I were Gilad Shalit’s father, I would do everything in my power to persuade Israel’s leaders to free my son at any price. I’d be a poor father if I did anything less. If I were a government official or army officer involved in the effort to free him, I’d be telling those same leaders the opposite. I’d remind them that, whatever the political pressures they face, and whatever their empathy for the plight of this one young man, they must take into account the consequences that any military operation or diplomatic deal inevitably would have for the security of Israel’s citizens, the lives of its other soldiers and Israel’s position when facing similar situations in the future. I’d be a poor policy adviser if I did anything less.

That’s why the ugly fact of Gilad Shalit’s long years in captivity leaves me frustrated and nonplused. I’m not Gilad’s father, but I am the father of a soldier. As such, I cannot escape the possibility that my son might fall prisoner to one of Israel’s enemies. My academic training in public policy lies many years in my past, but the ethos of dispassionate, objective and rational analysis of policy options that I learned as an undergraduate remains the foundation of my thinking about public affairs.

One of our required first-year courses was in rational decision-making theory. The professor opened the first class with the question, “How much money is a human life worth?”….

Read the rest in The Forward–Comment there or here.

2 thoughts on “Gilad Shalit’s Plight, And Israel’s Dilemma–<em>The Forward</em>”

  1. I think the government knows where he is, and I think he’s not in Gaza, and I think he’s so wired with explosives that the government knows any rescue attempt will be equivalent to murder.

  2. A thought provoking essay revolving around the case of one captured individual.

    But aren’t many lives captured by conflict, people held in situations over which they have little or no control though, unlike Shalit, they are allowed some degree of freedom?

    To me the death of any soldier or “martyr”, or imprisonment, formal or informal, with little chance of escape, should not be seen as a call by those dead or imprisoned for others to wage more war. Rather it is a call to end the madness, to change the overarching situation so that others do not follow them to the same fate.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.